You don't need to understand SEO to vet an SEO provider. You need six questions and a feel for what honest answers sound like. Ask me the same six — any provider worth hiring survives them.
By John Traugott, founder of RankFrost · Updated July 2026
The short answer
The pattern behind every question on this page: honest SEO work is explainable. A real provider can tell you what they'll do, show you what they did, connect it to calls and customers, and put your name on everything they build. Bad providers hide behind guarantees, jargon, secret methods, and reports nobody reads. You're not testing their SEO knowledge with these six questions — you're testing whether they'll operate in daylight. Ask all six, listen for plain English, and treat any “trust us, it's complicated” as your cue to leave.
Hear any of these and you have your answer, whatever the question was.
Ask them in order. Take notes. Plain English is the pass mark.
Good: specific deliverables — fix these profile issues, build these pages, clean up these listings, set up this tracking. Bad: “optimize your presence” and “build authority” with no nouns. If they can't name the work before you sign, they won't name it after.
Good: calls, direction requests, form fills — business outcomes, with tracking set up so you can see them yourself. Bad: rankings screenshots and impression charts. You can't deposit impressions.
Good: a concrete list on demand, because honest work has a paper trail. Bad: hesitation. This is the one question no bad agency survives, because invented specifics unravel under one follow-up.
Good: “You do — profile, domain, content, all of it. If we part ways, you keep everything.” Anything else, walk. This single answer predicts the entire relationship.
Good: real work compounds — pages, reviews, and fixes keep working after you stop paying. Bad: everything evaporates on cancellation, which quietly admits the results were rented, not built.
Good: an actual answer — competitive category, timeline expectations, things outside SEO's control. An honest provider knows the limits and says them. A provider with no downside to disclose is selling certainty they don't have. Timelines are honest limits too: here's what realistic looks like.
For local businesses, legitimate work typically runs a few hundred to a couple thousand a month by market and scope — the full honest breakdown is on the SEO pricing page. Both suspiciously cheap and impressively expensive fail the same test: what, specifically, is the money buying?
No. Google's results can't be guaranteed by anyone, and local rankings differ by searcher location anyway — there isn't even one “#1” to promise. Guarantee-led pitches are the industry's oldest tell.
Reports full of impressions but a phone that rings the same, no answer to “what did you do last month,” work you can't see (no new pages, no profile changes, no review growth), and renewal pressure whenever you ask questions. Two honest months of nothing is a firing offense; two years of it is common.
Size matters less than the six answers. That said, local providers can see your market, your competitors, and your actual business — and you can look them in the eye. Big shops often white-label local work out anyway; you're paying a markup for a middleman.
Then don't hire a bad one to feel productive — DIY the foundation instead. The fundamentals are genuinely doable yourself, and the honest split is laid out in DIY vs hiring. A cheap agency isn't a budget version of a good one; it's usually nothing in a monthly-invoice costume.
Please do — it's the point of the page. First 90 days: specific, written. Success metric: your phone. Last month's work: listed on request. Ownership: yours, always. If we stop: you keep everything. Why it might not work: I'll tell you on the call, honestly, before you spend a dollar.
Book a free 30-minute call and run all six questions on me. Worst case, you calibrate what honest answers sound like before you talk to anyone else — no obligation.
Request a Free Call →